1976

Bob Lemon

Robin Roberts

Freddie Lindstrom

Cal Hubbard

Oscar Charleston

Roger Connor

1975

Ralph Kiner

Earl Averill Sr.

Billy Herman

Bucky Harris

Judy Johnson

1974

Mickey Mantle

Whitey Ford

Jocko Conlan

Cool Papa Bell

Sam Thompson

Jim Bottomley

1973

Warren Spahn

Monte Irvin

Roberto Clemente

Mickey Welch

George Kelly

Billy Evans

1972

Sandy Koufax

Yogi Berra

Early Wynn

Buck Leonard

Lefty Gomez

Will Harridge

Josh Gibson

Ross Youngs

1971

Satchel Paige

Harry Hooper

Chick Hafey

Rube Marquard

Dave Bancroft

Jake Beckley

Joe Kelley

George Weiss

1970

Lou Boudreau

Earle Combs

Ford C. Frick

Jesse Haines

1969

Stan Musial

Roy Campanella

Waite Hoyt

Stan Coveleski

1968

Goose Goslin

Joe Medwick

Kiki Cuyler

1967

Red Ruffing

Lloyd Waner

Branch Rickey

1966

Ted Williams

Casey Stengel

1965

Pud Galvin

1964

Luke Appling

Burleigh Grimes

Red Faber

Heinie Manush

Miller Huggins

Tim Keefe

John Montgomery Ward

1963

Sam Rice

Eppa Rixey

Elmer Flick

John Clarkson

1962

Bob Feller

Jackie Robinson

Edd Roush

Bill McKechnie

1961

Max Carey

Billy Hamilton

1959

Zack Wheat

1957

Joe McCarthy

Sam Crawford

1956

Hank Greenberg

Joe Cronin

1955

Joe Dimaggio

Ray Schalk

Ted Lyons

Gabby Hartnett

Dazzy Vance

Frank Baker

1954

Bill Dickey

Bill Terry

Rabbit Maranville

1953

Dizzy Dean

Al Simmons

Chief Bender

Ed Barrow

Tom Connolly

Bill Klem

Bobby Wallace

Harry Wright

1952

Paul Waner

Harry Heilmann

1951

Jimmie Foxx

Mel Ott

1949

Charlie Gehringer

Kid Nichols

Mordecai Brown

1948

Pie Traynor

Herb Pennock

1947

Carl Hubbell

Mickey Cochrane

Frankie Frisch

Lefty Grove

1946

Jesse Burkett

Frank Chance

Jack Chesbro

Johnny Evers

Clark Griffith

Tommy McCarthy

Joe McGinnity

Eddie Plank

Joe Tinker

Rube Waddell

Ed Walsh

1945

Roger Bresnahan

Dan Brouthers

Fred Clarke

Jimmy Collins

Ed Delahanty

Hugh Duffy

Hughie Jennings

King Kelly

Jim O'Rourke

Wilbert Robinson

1944

Kennesaw Landis

1942

Rogers Hornsby

1939

Lou Gehrig

George Sisler

Charlie Radbourn

Eddie Collins

Willie Keeler

Al Spalding

Cap Anson

Charlie Comiskey

Candy Cummings

Buck Ewing

1938

Grover Cleveland Alexander

Alexander Cartwright

Henry Chadwick

1937

Cy Young

Ban Johnson

Napoleon Lajoie

Tris Speaker

Connie Mack

John McGraw

Morgan Bulkeley

George Wright

1936

Ty Cobb

Babe Ruth

Honus Wagner

Christy Mathewson

Walter Johnson